Wednesday, July 25, 2007 Capitol
Hill Watch
House Democrats Unveil SCHIP Legislation That Would
Increase Cigarette Tax, Reduce Payments to Medicare Advantage
Plans
House Democrats on Tuesday introduced
legislation that would reduce payments to Medicare Advantage plans and
increase the federal cigarette tax by 45 cents per pack to fund SCHIP and
make revisions to Medicare, the AP/Houston Chronicle reports (Freking,
AP/Houston Chronicle, 7/24). The legislation, called the
Children's Health and Medicare Protection Act, would reauthorize SCHIP and
increase funding for the program by $50 billion over five years. The
expansion would allow an additional five million to six million children
to enroll in the program, according to House Energy and
Commerce Committee Chair John Dingell (D-Mich.) (Johnson [1],
CongressDaily, 7/25).
In addition, the legislation
would:
- Delay scheduled Medicare physician payment cuts
totaling 10% in 2008 and 5% in 2009 and replace them with 0.5% increases
in each of the next two years;
- Create a mechanism for physicians to give
feedback on treatment resources compared with their peers for similar
beneficiaries and create a pilot program in which doctors get paid to
provide a "medical home" to coordinate care;
- Increase Medicare benefits for preventive care
and mental health care, raise the value of assets low-income seniors can
have and still qualify for the Medicare prescription drug benefit and
cover more out-of-pocket Medicare costs for lower-income elderly
beneficiaries;
- Equalize payments between MA plans and
Medicare's traditional fee-for-service program by 2011;
- Reduce payments to home health agencies,
skilled nursing facilities, inpatient rehabilitation facilities and
long-term acute care hospitals;
- Eliminate a "trigger" provision in the 2003
Medicare law that requires the president to propose legislation on
reducing Medicare spending if the program's trustees find for two years
in a row that Medicare is projected to draw more than 45% of its funding
from general government revenues;
- Eliminate co-insurance and waive the deductible
for current preventive benefits covered by Medicare;
- Reduce payments for mental health services from
the current 5% copayment to the standard 20%; and
- Give Medicare the authority to use
recommendations by the U.S. Preventative Health Services Task Force to add new
preventive benefits without congressional approval (Carey/Reichard, CQ HealthBeat, 7/24).
The bill
is expected to cost about $90 billion. The tobacco tax increase is
projected to raise about $27 billion and MA plan reimbursement reductions
will raise close to $50 billion, according to House Ways and Means
Health Subcommittee Chair Pete Stark (D-Calif.). In
addition, savings from reductions in payments to home health, skilled
nursing and rehabilitation providers will be used to fund the measure
(Johnson [1],
CongressDaily, 7/25). The reductions in
payments are consistent with recommendations from the
Medicare Payment Advisory
Commission (
CQ HealthBeat, 7/24).
SCHIP Eligibility
Under the bill, states would continue to
have the option of applying for waivers to provide SCHIP coverage to
adults and higher-income children, according to House Energy and Commerce
Health Subcommittee Chair Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) (Johnson
[1], CongressDaily, 7/25). States also would have the option
of enrolling in SCHIP certain low-income pregnant women and documented
immigrant children and pregnant women. In addition, the legislation would
give the states the option to enroll in Medicaid and SCHIP children up to
age 24. States would receive higher payments for following specific
practices intended to increase enrollment and would receive payment
adjustments if they run out of funds enrolling eligible children. States
would have two years to spend the federal allotment received each year.
The House bill is expected to cover two million more children than the
Senate version of the legislation approved last week by the Senate Finance
Committee but estimates from the Congressional Budget Office are not yet available for the
House proposal.
Medicare Advantage
The bill would equalize payments between
MA plans and traditional Medicare over five years, reducing federal
reimbursements by close to $50 billion over that time period. The bill
would not change the reimbursement rates in 2008, but in 2009, payment
benchmarks to MA plans would be a mix of two-thirds of the current private
plan payment system and one-third of traditional Medicare rates. In 2010,
payment benchmarks would be a mix of one-third of the current private plan
payment system and two-thirds of the traditional Medicare rates. Payments
would be equalized in 2011, with plans that fail to bid below the reduced
benchmarks barred from enrolling new members that year.
Physician Reimbursement Changes
Under the bill, a scheduled
cut in Medicare payments to physicians would be reversed and physicians
would receive a 0.5% increase in fees for each of the next two years. In
addition, the bill would make revisions to the system that sets spending
targets for Medicare outlays for physicians' care. Rather than setting a
single spending target for all Medicare care, the system would sort
outlays into six different categories with different spending targets for
each category. The categories include: primary and preventive care; other
evaluation and management services; anesthesia; imaging; major procedures;
and minor procedures.
Outlays that surpass spending targets must
be offset in following years in the form of payment reductions. The
reimbursement revisions are "meant to increase incentives for doctors not
to overprescribe tests, visits and procedures," according to CQ
HealthBeat. The bill also provides for a "bundled payment" system
for dialysis facilities to encourage proper dosage of anemia drugs to
dialysis patients. The reimbursement revision provision also creates a
mechanism to provide physicians with feedback on the level of treatment
resources they prescribe as compared to peers who treat similar
beneficiaries (CQ HealthBeat, 7/24).
Senate Republican Alternative Bill
In related news, Senate
Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) circulated a letter to Senate
Republicans announcing his plans to offer a "comprehensive" alternative to
the bipartisan SCHIP legislation when the bill moves to the Senate floor,
CQ HealthBeat reports. The Republican version would cost less
than the Senate and House proposals and would increase the use of health
savings accounts and small-business health insurance purchasing pools,
according to the letter (Reichard, CQ HealthBeat, 7/24). The
bill would limit eligibility to children in families with incomes at 200%
of the federal poverty level or lower. Children who currently are enrolled
in the program and are in families with incomes greater than that level
would continue to receive coverage until income redistributions are made,
according to aides familiar with the plan.
The bill would not
allow states to seek federal waivers to provide coverage for nonpregnant
adults and would bar states from disregarding portions of income when
determining eligibility. The proposal would cost an estimated $9 billion
over five years, according to CongressDaily (Johnson [2],
CongressDaily, 7/25).
McConnell said other Republican
senators were concerned about "the size of the plan that came out of the
Finance Committee and what that may portend for the future in terms of an
entire government takeover of American health care and, in essence, a
single-payer system down the road" (Pear, New York Times, 7/25). The Republican bill
"will likely not stop the bipartisan bill from getting the 60 votes needed
to cut off a filibuster," although it will "attract support from many
Republicans," according to CongressDaily
(CongressDaily, 7/25).
Impact
SCHIP reauthorization and expansion "serves as a
warm-up for a future debate on how best to revamp the entire U.S. health
care system," provide coverage to the uninsured and "rein in climbing
medical costs," the Wall Street Journal reports. The
differences between House and Senate versions of the legislation put the
two chambers "on a collision course with" each other and with President
Bush, who has proposed providing an additional $5 billion over five years
for SCHIP, the Journal reports.
The House bill "shows
how difficult it can be to make any changes to health programs, as
powerful industries lobby hard for payment increases or to ward off big
cuts," according to the Journal. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa)
said that a $35 billion increase for the program is the limit for
Republican lawmakers and that while Senate Democrats "might want something
bigger, ... I think we went as far as we can as Republicans" (Lueck,
Wall Street Journal, 7/25).
In addition, the
combination of a "potentially difficult vote for some Democrats," the
"prospect of a presidential veto and rough ride in the Senate" has led
some "to question the point of moving forward" with the legislation,
according to CongressDaily. Lawmakers must reauthorize the
program by Sept. 30th or it will expire (Johnson,
CongressDaily, 7/24).
Opinion Piece
"Reauthorizing the SCHIP state-federal
partnership this fall is a good idea" but "[i]nviting more and richer
adults into a children's welfare program is not," Rep. Joe Barton
(R-Texas), ranking member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee,
writes in a Washington Times opinion piece. Barton writes
that "practical ways" to "fix health care" include "allowing small
employers to consolidate their purchasing power so they can offer health
insurance without losing their shirts"; making "health costs transparent
and empower consumers to shop"; and reducing "the threat of ... gotcha
malpractice suits" so that "health care inflation can cool" (Barton,
Washington Times, 7/25).